Latin Quotes, Sayings, Tattoos, Phrases & Mottos

Most texts and materials on this site have to do with the Latin language, including its perception in popular culture: movies, tattoos, inscriptions, engravings, bits of ancient philosophy, online Latin resources and company names. There is also information about learning Latin and Greek: textbooks, dictionaries, DVDs and software that can be used in a homeschooling environment.


"A room without books is like a body without a soul"

 
Monday, October 22, 2007, 08:35 - Latin Language, Legal Phrases and Expressions
Posted by Administrator
Found a true treasure trove of pseudo-Cicero-inspired merchandise:

http://www.cafepress.com/fsotherstuff/823969

Once again, Cicero is not directly responsible for this quote.

The fact is that the saying itself is not that bad. It's just sad that we cannot attribute it to someone else. Really, would it have killed Cicero to say something to the same effect? I'll tell you why.

Books simply did not mean the same to Cicero, as they do to us. He did not have to be in direct contact with the learned tomes of his time. That's what slaves were for. They copied books, read them out loud and organized them. A writer of Roman times was rather detached from his media. You could be a man of letters and never pick up a calamus. Or a book, for that matter. And even if one wanted to use books it was not that easy. You simply could not simply crack open a volume and find a quote that you needed or verify some idea. It would take many minutes of attentive scrolling. Dealing with books was akin to manual labor, something that a free Roman would rather not be a part of. So, even if you were into literature you would not hold books in a particularly high esteem, methinks. It may appear odd, but there is a reason why the term for a scribe, Librariolus, is reminiscent of the contemptuous Graeculus.

A Roman man of letters inevitably remained less involved with books as physical objects of intrinsic cultural significance, often dealing instead with their mental projections. These projections were associated with rather fluid textual data, because the limited ability to open a papyrus on any given passage and the lack of visual contact with books during recitation stood in the way of developing the very notion of textual integrity. Perhaps, the appeal of the pseudo-Ciceronian adage is due to the fact that for us “a room with books” has a deeper meaning – that of a multidimensional microcosm where myriads of definitive semantic streams can be instantly reached, consulted and analyzed. This distinction setting apart the ancient and the modern worlds of books may seem too subtle, but one only needs to imagine the frustration that would occur if all the pages in someone’s library were suddenly glued together to form scrolls. Would we still consider that room full of books?

To put it simply, the comparison of books in a room with a soul in a body only works well with books as we know them.

See also:
Home library design
  permalink   |  related link

<<First <Back | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | Next> Last>>





Privacy Policy